7 comments

• 

  whollamellie

  1 year ago

  i think somehow your award is very much bias
  reply
• 

  Michael

  1 year ago

  Biased? Towards whom? Against whom?
  
  You'll see a lot of players from the "Big Four" there, but that's because they're the four best teams in the league. Am I supposed to give awards to players and teams that are near the bottom of the table?
  reply
• 

  JaBbA

  1 year ago

  Actually, I think the list is very good. I might argue with Best Striker, but I'm a little biased as a Pool fan, and Anelka is looking like he _should_ have at Anfield. I think Martin O'neill doesn't get enough credit at Villa. I might put Elano as biggest surprise, but RSC absolutely is up there.
  
  And as much as I can't stand him, Ronaldo is an amazing player. I'd probably like him if he was wearing a different shade of red. :-)
  reply
• 

  TheScout

  1 year ago

  I don't agree with your choice for worst manager.
  
  I think it should go to someone like Lawrie Sanchez or Sammy Lee. Lee had Bolton dead last before Megson took over. Now with the same group of players, they are climbing their way back up the table. You could excuse Lee by saying he inherited a team and philosophy from Allardyce but Megson has gone back to what works with that group of players and that's good management. Getting the most out of what you have.
  
  Sanchez inherited an average squad from Chris Coleman, was given money to improve it and has actually taken the club a step backwards it seems. Sanchez spent £26.5 million in the summer window on 12 players, but could not get them to gel as a team. He was given half a season and it'll be interesting to see if Hodgson can do any better.
  
  I do think Allardyce deserves a bit of time before he's completely relegated to the scrap heap. It takes a while to overhaul a team. He has spent money over the summer but at least Newcastle are sitting 11th. January is going to be tough for them as they play ManUtd and Arsenal and will be without Abdoulaye Faye, Habib Beye, Geremi and Obafemi Martins.
  reply
• 

  Michael

  1 year ago

  For worst manager, I only considered those who still had their job.
  
  If that wasn't the case, it would've been a dead heat between Billy Davies and Sammy Lee, with Lawrie Sanchez only a notch above those because he had considerable injuries and bad breaks to deal with.
  reply
• 

  TheScout

  1 year ago

  Ahh...OK. I better understand your rationale now.
  reply
• 

  get_bent99

  1 year ago

  I think that MOP and MVP is pretty much the same thing anyway so there's not really much point in giving two awards to Ronaldo. I agree with you on most of these awards. But best striker has got to be Adebayor or Torres. I think that Fabregas and Ashley Young has a shout at best midfielder as well. For best centerback I would say that Laursen, Dunne and Lescott did better than Carragher. Nugent and Halford were worst signings than Malouda. Although Santa Cruz did very well, I would consider him more as a best signing contender rather than a biggest surprise because he wasn't really a bad player to start with. I would go with Flamini as the biggest surprise just because he ousted Brazil captain Gilberto from the starting lineup and pushed Arsenal to the top of the table. Elano is another option but if you knew about Elano before he was a very good player anyway and like Santa Cruz he is considered as a best summer signing contender. Either than this, you have everything else pretty much spot on. Although there is definitely more than one goal of the season contender but Larsson's goal was also magnificent. And yes the 4-4 match between Chelsea and Villa was amazing right till the end.
  reply