DISQUS

DISQUS Hello! EPL Talk is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

EPL Talk

Daily News & Analysis of the English Premier League
Jump to original thread »
Author

Poll: Did Vidic Foul Blackburn Goalkeeper Jason Brown?

Started by The Gaffer · 9 months ago

It was the big talking point from this weekend’s game at Ewood Park. Should Manchester United’s first goal been disallowed because Vidic backed in to Blackburn goalkeeper Jason Brown and elbowed him in the face, or - as the commentators mentioned - it was Brown’ ... Continue reading »

11 comments

  • Simon Burke.

    9 months ago

    Foul , intentional or not (it wasnt) he catches the keeper with an elbow in the face
    as he goes for the ball - Vidic never gets the ball so it has to be impeding.
    reply
  • HN

    9 months ago

    Clear foul, intentional or not. Whether Brown should have been more commanding in his box or not is irrelevant.
    reply
  • Raatzie

    9 months ago

    Brown needed to take a page from Ronaldo's book and drop over as if he'd been shot.
    reply
  • enKore

    9 months ago

    lol @ raatzie..though i am a united fan i couldn't suppress a chuckle!
    reply
  • Todd

    9 months ago

    typical abu answers...it was never a foul. brown is built like a brick house and was hardly impeded. if you go out like a wet towel, you cant cry foul. if anything vidic was pushed into him...but everyone has a fair shot at the ball in my view
    reply
  • Auslander25

    9 months ago

    If the same thing happened outside of the six yard box I'd say no foul. Inside the six yard box, you have to call a foul there. I don't know how the ref didn't wave it off. Oh wait, the ref was Steve Bennett...
    reply
  • Django

    9 months ago

    "if you go out like a wet towel, you cant cry foul"...your thoughts on ronaldo, then?
    reply
  • Raatzie

    9 months ago

    Hee hee hee.
    reply
  • Todd

    9 months ago

    when someone kicks at your ankle while you are running full speed and you fall to the ground...its usually a foul. if a 250lbs keeper comes out for the ball and gets knocked down from minimal contact, then he gets less consideration. then again i hate how the keeper usually gets every single call for contact in the box. i prefer to favor the attacking player
    reply
  • Raatzie

    9 months ago

    Unless he's playing ManUre, of course.
    reply
  • stretford

    9 months ago

    y'all sceptics are way too blind.
    go watch the replays properly, santa cruz clearly wasnt eyeing the ball, he was pushing vidic towards brown instead.
    how else would vidic lean into brown unintentionally?
    surely u guys wont consider santa cruz fouling cos the decision was between brown and vidic.
    if anything, it should either end up as a wes brown goal or a penalty.
    go ahead watch the replays.
    reply

Add New Comment

Returning? Login