DISQUS

Hello! EPL Talk is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

www.epltalk.com Jump to website »

Subscribe
- New Comments
Community
Top Commenters
- kkfla737
  345 comments · 2 points
- The Gaffer
  164 comments · 1 points
- ls7
  100 comments · 2 points
- AtlantaPompey
  69 comments · 3 points
- BishopvilleRed
  46 comments · 1 points
Popular Threads
Recent Comments
- Iain who? exactly worst piece of garbage i have heard in my entire life? two european cup finals in the space of three years, how long did it take Sir PinkNosed ferguson to win his first european...
  5 months ago by avy
  
  in Did one substitution forever curse Rafa Benitez’s Liverpool?
- Michael Timbury is obviously a mug with no brains
  5 months ago by Donny
  
  in Arsenal Or Villa: Who Is Your Favourite In The Race For Fourth Place?
- if any thing this proves that who ever wrote this article is racist as he clearly generalises both sets of supporters which is a racist trait
  5 months ago by beyethegreat
  
  in Who Would You Rather See Relegated: Tottenham or Newcastle?
- I agree he was always a defensive coach but the point he has simply become so entrenched in his 'holier than thou' single-minded beliefs, that there is no way back. If Liverpool ever win...
  5 months ago by Iain Liddle
  
  in Did one substitution forever curse Rafa Benitez’s Liverpool?
- what a rubbish article
  5 months ago by Ben
  
  in Did one substitution forever curse Rafa Benitez’s Liverpool?

EPL Talk

Daily News & Analysis of the English Premier League

Jump to original thread »

Measuring the quality of the EPL

Started by The Gaffer · 10 months ago

If you took the 20 clubs in the English Premiership and had to sort them into three different categories (”Masterful,” “Mediocre” and “Anti-Soccer”), which teams would go into what buckets?
Interesting question, ... Continue reading »

7 comments

JC
3 years ago

You have Man U as a mediocre team. You're kidding, right? I can't stand them either, but they're clearly in the Masterful group.

If your list is strictly based on this season, then I agree (except for Man U).

If we're talking long-term though, I'd say there are the 4 super powers (Chelsea, Arsenal, Man U, Liverpool), a few teams that have been at that level and/or could reach that level (Blackburn, Newcastle, Spurs, Villa) and the rest that are hoping for a Roman Abromovich-type miracle.

reply

LoRo
3 years ago

If your article was not about money creating a divide in the EPL calling Wigan masterful would be acceptable.

However they are a great example of what a 'poor' club is able to achieve in a special season.

reply

Anonymous
3 years ago

Wigan over Man U? Wigan is a fluke. Man U sits at second in the Premiership right now.

reply

Yam
3 years ago

If this is based on current performance then Arsenal and not Man Utd. Should be in the mediocre bucket.

reply

The Gaffer
3 years ago

Good comments by everyone. I should clarify that the three categories are based on the team's current excitement level, not position within the table.

Man United was one of the team's that I was considering for "Masterful," but their performances of late, other than their huge win against Liverpool, have left much to be desired. Just in the past few weeks, they've lost against Blackburn and Man City.

Wigan is definitely the anomaly. They haven't spend millions, but their performances and never-say-die attitude have been astounding.

reply

JC
3 years ago

Hasn't this always been the case with English football? Hasn't it always been a league where there are 2-3 great teams and the rest a notch down? I've only been following the league for about 10 years so I'm not familiar enough with the history to know for sure. From what I've read though, it seems like this is the way it's always been.

And isn't it the same in every European league. And more importantly, doesn't it have to be? If there was a level of parity akin to the NFL - where one year a team is good and the next they're awful - the Champions League and other various European competitions would be invalidated (or at least, horrendous to watch). In European soccer it seems like there's a need for dynasties.

Thoughts?

reply